Love Island All Stars is digging up all sorts of goss from the Islanders about how they know each other, and their past relationships. First Georgia Steel revealed she was close friends with Luis Morrison’s ex, then Georgia Harrison explained why she and Joshua Ritchie fell out in Ibiza. And now, bombshell Arabella Chi has shared that she and Toby Aromolaran have slept together in the past – but how does that match up with his break up from Chloe Burrows?
Wow, that’s a lot of information to take in, isn’t it? Here’s a breakdown of all the dates you need to know, in case you need a refresher.
Chloe and Toby met in summer 2021, and dated until autumn 2022
Chloe and Toby met in the Love Island 2021 villa, and seemed to go from strength to strength after making it to the final week of the show.
But sadly it wasn’t to be; they broke up in October 2022, with Chloe opened up about their relationship on Celebs Go Dating, explaining, “He was probably the nicest person I’ve been with. When he said this is not working, I was really heartbroken for months,” she said.
“Things were going well and then fell apart and we both knew. We hadn’t seen each other in a month,” she added, in tears. “I wasn’t ready for it to end then.”
Toby also opened up about their split in the All Stars villa, explaining “something big happened” where “I didn’t trust her anymore.”
Toby and Georgia S met in September 2023
Fast forward to September 2023, almost a year later, and Toby competed in Love Island Games, where he met Georgia Steel. The pair grew close on the show before being dumped from the villa, and have been trying to rekindle things in the All Star house.
“That might be unfinished business, to be fair,” Toby said about Georgia in the pre-Love Island All Stars press round table interview. “Like if she came in, I feel like we’ll definitely have to speak about the Games and, obviously, how we left together and like how we were going.
“But yeah, it’s one of those ones where it’ll be interesting to see if she does come in; it’ll be interesting to see her and I think it’ll be interesting for her to see me as well.”
Arabella says she and Toby dated “a year and a half ago”, July 2022
Only, er, Arabella threw a spanner in the works with her arrival. The latest bombshell landed in the villa on Friday [19th January], telling the girls that she and Toby have “history” from “a year and a half ago.” She told Demi they had slept together (although Toby told the boys they didn’t), while they both admitted to texting for a while.
A year and a half ago would mean the summer of 2022 – which is prior to news breaking that he and Chloe had broken up. “Toby, we hooked up in the summer,” Arabella said later. “There is a little bit of unfinished business there.”
Hmm, maybe she’s got her timelines confused? Does she mean summer 2023? Summer in LA, aka, all year round? She did later admit she wasn’t 100% sure of when it happened, so maybe that explains it.
Love Island All Stars continues at 9pm on ITV2.
Sophie Anderson, a UK-based writer, is your guide to the latest trends, viral sensations, and internet phenomena. With a finger on the pulse of digital culture, she explores what’s trending across social media and pop culture, keeping readers in the know about the latest online sensations.
